Upper Elementary - The Whole Truth

The month of November is Indigenous Peoples Month (Native American Heritage Month) and it has provided an opportunity for many rich classroom conversations. It is important to honor the full history. This includes the tragic parts and the accomplishments of the people. While November is dedicated to highlighting these themes, it's important to honor Indigenous people throughout the year.
We just wrapped up reading the historical fiction novel Soft Rain by Cornelia Cornellisen. The author, of Cherokee (Tsalagi) heritage, was inspired by stories of her great-grandfather and his family's experience traveling the Trail of Tears. We not only learned about the heartbreak of families torn apart, lives lost and communities displaced, but also the resilience of so many indigenous people as they took this dangerous journey and reestablished a homeland.
As we head into Thanksgiving break, we took some time to think about the question, What is Thanksgiving? The class shared: time to be with family, enjoy special foods, express gratitude... Then we read the article below, Thanksgiving is Also a Day of Mourning (Read Works). We were faced with the whole truth about the story we've often heard about the "First Thanksgiving". Yes, there was a shared meal between the Wampanoag and pilgrims in Plymouth. That "peace" lasted about 50 years, followed by war, disease, displacement and according to some historians the death of 90% of the Wampanoag. Once again, we were faced with the question of why telling the whole story is important.
In discussion, many profound ideas were shared. One that stood out to me was the idea that telling a partial truth is a lie of omission. This can benefit us in various ways - keep us out of trouble, make us look better in the situation, give us power or diminish another. The danger in doing that is we risk convincing ourselves of that lie and therefor repeating our mistakes.
We learned that we can hold space for more than one truth. In this case, the joys of family traditions at a special holiday gathering and also understand how the same holiday is a day of mourning.
How Thanksgiving is Also a Day of Mourning
A Poem for the Season - Gratitude by Mary Oliver





Comments